The Request of Xiangling: A Controversial Case on Silencing
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.61173/j09s6b10Keywords:
Dream of the Red Chamber, Austin’s speech act theory, illocutionary silencing, Xiangling learning poetryAbstract
Dream of the Red Chamber has been one of the well-known novels in China, which has contributed to an area named “redology.” In the realm of redology, there are a lot of controversies about the silencing of Xiangling’s request for Baochai (one main character of the Red Chamber) to teach her poetry. However, few researchers have tried to analyze this conversation through a linguistic angle. This paper will introduce the Austinian approach to silencing to this controversial case in Dream of the Red Chamber, which could make essential distinctions between important concepts, and provide a coherent explanation for the reason why Xiangling insisted on her specific request to learn poetry and why Baochai had such systematic recognition failures. Through the case study, this paper proves that Xiangling suffers illocutionary silencing in her conversation with Baochai by refuting possible counterarguments. It is significant not only to the explanation of this novel, but also to expansion of application of Austin’s speech act theory.
References
[1] Jiang Hesen. Draft on a Dream of Red Mansions [M]. People’s Literature Publishing House,1959
[2] Wang Wei, Feng Lu. “Beauty” and “dullness” : The Diachronic representation of Xiang Ling’s Poetic Life [J]. New Oriental,2019,(01):67-75.
[3] Ding Wei. The double implication of “madness” and “stupidness” in the dream of Red Mansions. Journal of Jinan Party School, 2019, 2:5.
[4] Hornsby, J. Speech Acts and Pornography. Women’s Philosophy Review, 1993, 10: 38-45.
[5] Austin J L. Speech acts[J]. 1962.
[6] McGowan, M.K. On Silencing and Sexual Refusal. The Journal of Political Philosophy, 2009, 17(4): 487-494.
[7] McGowan, M.K. On Multiple Types of Silencing, M. Mikkola (ed.), Beyond Speech. Pornography and Analytic Feminist Philosophy. New York: Oxford University Press, 2017, 39-58.
[8] Caponetto, L. A comprehensive definition of illocutionary silencing. Topoi, 2021, 40(1): 191-202.
[9] Cao Yue. The personality of “spoony disease” in A Dream of Red Mansions -- taking Lin Daiyu as an example. New Chu Culture. 2023, 4: 30-34.
[10] Zhang Lihong & He Di. Moon Poetry from the depths of the subconscious: A psychoanalytic analysis of Xiang Ling’s dream of “learning poetry”. Journal of Neijiang Normal University, 2021, 11:1-6.
[11] Brown P, Levinson S C. Politeness: Some universals in language usage[M]. Cambridge university press, 1987.
[12] Grice H P. Logic and conversation[M]//Speech acts. Brill, 1975: 41-58.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 by the authors.
This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
