Subtle but Invulnerable: Feminists Breaking through Red Chambers and Prejudiced Pride
DOI:
https://doi.org/10.61173/4gmr4619Keywords:
Feminism, Pride and Prejudice, A Dream in Red Mansions, emotionality, education, growthAbstract
The paper is dedicated to the analysis of differences and resemblances of feminism consciousness between Elizabeth Bennet and Lin Daiyu, the protagonists in Pride and Prejudice and a Dream in Red Mansions. The two works are considered pioneering greatly because female characters are of vital importance, breaking the narrative traditions. The paper, capturing this mutual transcendence, examines the two works through a feminism scope, and explores how social background influences feminism ideals by introducing the measurement “feminism applicability” for evaluation of Daiyu and Elizabeth’s respective feminism, and aims to argue that society determines, both shapes internally and affects exteriorly, applicability of feminism. By applying the comparative analysis method, the writer finally concludes that Ming-Qing and British Enlightenment triggers females’ recognition towards self, which contributes to their mutual emotionality; however, demand for rationality, females’ rights of speech and prevailing ideologies differentiate in two societies, thus their strength of need for self-judgement and autonomy is differed, resulting in different levels of feminism applicability.
References
other hand, in terms of rationality, education ideals and Red Mansions. Journal of Harbin University, 2017, 38(2): 67-70. optimism. This is caused by their different social inter- [2]Johnson, P. Feminism and the Enlightenment. Radical
pretations of rationality, societal expectations implied in Philosophy, 1993, 63: 3-12. Enlightenment and prevailing principles. [3]Zhang Z. A comparative study of female consciousness in Enlightenment aroused both females’ self-awareness. Chinese and English academic works. Xi’ an University of
Focus on self interest and realization of masculine sup- Technology, 2017: MA thesis. pression woke females up and raise consciousness of their [4]Cao X.Q. A dream of red mansions. Asiapac Books Pte Ltd, independent existences. Daiyu’s and Elizabeth’s emotion- 1978. ality are crystallization of Enlightenment. [5]Guo M. The inheritance and development of female During Ming-Qing Enlightenment, people focus on famil- consciousness in the Dream of Red Mansions from the Story of ial interest instead of that of a particular sex, thus women the West Chamber and the Peony Pavilion. Journal of Nanjing
were still represented by men when earliest feminism was Normal University (Social Science Edition), 2005, 5: 124-129. burgeoning. The peak of feudal ethics also maximized the [6]Austen, J. Pride and prejudice. Broadview Press, 2001. effect of feudal morals on women, expecting them not to [7]Asker, R. Money and Love in Jane Austen’s Pride and be critical and insightful enough to spot the flaws of men Prejudice, 2012. dominance, which resulted in the vagueness, turbulence [8]Luo J. H. Patriarchal ethics and female tragedy: the influence and low applicability of Daiyu’s feminism. However, En- of Confucianism on ancient Chinese love works. Guangdong
lightenment for England is inclined towards masculinity, social sciences, 1994, 2: 104-107. women who realized their feminine powers could only [9]De Beauvoir, S. The second sex. In Social Theory Re-Wired,
fight their way through on their own, hence feeling more pp. 2016: 367-377. responsible and determined of their approaches. Under [10]Wollstonecraft, M. Vindication of the Rights of Woman. In
this circumstance, females are more encouraged to voice Democracy: a reader, 2016: pp. 297-306. Columbia University out their opinions compared to a monopolistic-masculine Press. society, hence rewarding Austen and Elizabeth the oppor- [11]Chen Y.S., Zhang X. Reflections of Confucianism In a dream
tunity to develop a practical feminism theory and enhance of red mansions.” 1991, Dongyue essays 2: 84-87. their feminism applicability. [12]Wang, X., & Liu, Y. Analysis of the Feminism in Pride Collectivism and individualism also affected both charac- and Prejudice. Theory and Practice in Language Studies, 2011, ters. Due to the low confidence and hostile societal condi- 1(12): 1827-1830.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
Copyright (c) 2024 by the authors.

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License.
